Scenzilla is temporarily taking some breaks from writing about smelly things during this month, so that I can discuss another fun beauty obsession, mascara. I’ve got some keen faves, and some not-so-keen faves.
My favorite drugstore mascara is Physician’s Formula Retro-Glow. It’s the closest I’ve ever come to looking like I’m wearing false lashes without actually having to wear false lashes. It thickens, it lengthens, and it oomphasizes (portmanteau of oomph and emphasize… patent pending!) every last lash. It’s got one drawback: the wand. It sure does look cute, but I worry it might be a pain for some folks, since holding it is akin to grasping at the end of a bubble-blowing wand. I don’t personally feel it’s really that tricky to use, but I figured I better mention it. I do like the brush on the end, so I skip using my own wand for it. The mascara tends to smear a bit by the end of the day, but not too badly.
Sadly, all the other mascaras I’ve tried by Physician’s Formula, aside from the Retro, are simply horrendous. Their Lash-In-A-Tube? More like Suck-In-A-Tube. The “tube” is a meaningless gimmick that has no bearing on the performace of the product; the brush is so huge it seems to have been sized for the eyeballs of people straight out of Margaret Keene paintings; the forumla would be fine were it not prone to flaking off like so much asbestos on a 1970s popcorn ceiling. Both their Eyebrightener and To Any Length mascaras perform equally as ignominiously as the Suck-In-A-Tube. While the brushes get no complaints from me, the effect from either one looks like I just coated my lashes in some random dark gunk I pulled out of a broken sink drain. That’s all I got out of them. Both went into the trash the same week I bought them. I really do not understand how they managed to create pure awesomeness with their Retro-Glow, and then fail with these others. I wouldn’t have even tried them all in vain had the Retro-Glow not been THAT awesome.
The absolute cheapest mascara I like is N.Y.C’s (New York Color) Lengthening Mascara. I can usually get it on sale for a buck to a buck-fifty. It will not do a thing for thickening or volume, so please don’t go looking for that in this product. But it does lengthen all right, and it looks remarkably natural. Sadly, it does smear and run on me within I’d say around four or five hours, but this is something I like to correct with a much more spendy product…
… the Smashbox Layer Lash Primer. Yes, buying a $14 mascara primer pretty much defeats the purpose budget-wise of buying a $1 mascara, but I swear the combination of the two is awesome.
This primer works best with mascaras that have slightly wet formulas, like the N.Y.C Lengthening (or Smashbox’s own mascara.) I think the best way to use it is to go eye by eye, rather than layer by layer, if that makes sense. I coat only one eye’s lashes in the primer, then let it set for about 15-30 seconds, and next apply my mascara while the primer is still just a bit wet and sticky. THEN I move on to the other eye. No matter which mascara I use, the Smashbox primer seems to keep any smearing in check, so I don’t wind up with undereye smudges that make me look like the world’s most unlikely football player. It lasts all day and all night, too, with no need to “refresh” anything. It may not be waterproof, but unlike waterproof mascaras this primer does not dry my lashes out.
You CAN get some drugstore selections that come with both primer and mascara. The only one I’ve tried is Revlon’s Lash Fantasy. Oh, how I wished this had worked well on my lashes. Alas, if this is a fantasy, then it’s the fantasy of someone who is so timid they can’t be expressive even in their own dreams. The mascara half was slightly too dry, and flaked off like crazy, both with the primer and without. The primer is slightly better, actually, but it’s too gunky and thick for my lashes, and the brush didn’t help matters because it clung to the gunk and then deposited it as chunks of gunk. Which meant I had to pick through my primer-coated lashes with a comb before applying mascara. This meant extra drying time for the primer, and I feel primers work best when the mascara is put over them when still just a tad wet rather than when dry. I suppose it might work for someone with thinner lashes than mine? I’m not sure. I bought this on a buy one, get one free deal, and gave the other tube to my sister, who was even less enthused by it than me. I think she may have even actively hated it.
So on the related topic of lash combs and mascara brushes, there are some I would like to single out as particularly well done.
My favorite ever combination lash and eyebrow brush is Shu Uemura’s Synthetic Eyebrow Brush. It’s nicely sized for travel, and a slight thickness towards end of the handle makes it easy to hold. The brush is quite soft and non-irritating, and while they say the comb is good for brows, I think it works pretty good for combing through the lashes, too. At $10, it’s one of the better deals on high end make-up brushes, second only to CARGO’s kick-ass Kolinsky eyeliner brush. (As a sidenote on the CARGO brush, yes I know it got two crummy reviews on Beauty.com. I can’t imagine why. The only trouble is that the handle is too long by half, but for that price I don’t care. The quality of the brush head is superb. When washing and drying your brushes, please remember to reshape them while still wet, and please dry them with the tips hanging out on the edge of a box or a counter so air can move evenly around the brush head. Or dry them hanging upside down if possible. When washing, DO NOT EVER pull on the hairs, because you will eventually start to loosen and pull them out of the spot inside the ferrule where they are tied and glued. Uh, sorry. Mini-rant about proper brush care over now, I promise.)
The absolute best eyelash comb I’ve ever used is Tarte’s metal comb on the end of the Lash/Mascara Comb. I’m bummed that I can’t buy the comb as a single brush, rather than as a double brush. Nevertheless I’m glad to have that puppy around.
I have two favorite mascara brushes. One might question why anyone would need to buy these, but I’ve found that while some mascaras have a great formula, they may not be packaged with a very stellar brush. Moreover, they are handy for when one simply needs to brush through a botched mascara application rather than needing to pick through it.
One I really like is the one made by Versace. The brush is so soft, but full, and the wooden handle is so thin and strong that I have yet to encounter the mascara tube it doesn’t fit into. No wait, I take that back. Pout’s mascara tube is too skinny for it to fit into. But that’s okay, because you can totally skip their mascara anyhow. Ha! The Versace makeup line has been steadily disappearing from sight, which is heartbreaking because they made some killer products. Luckily for those who don’t already have this brush, it is being sold at a discount via Strawberrynet.com. (And get their blush brush, too - holy cow! It’s, like, so perfect it’s practically makeup zen.) Neiman Marcus used to carry the line, but I don’t see it on their online site anymore, sigh.
The other mascara brush I love, that I can’t find anywhere at ALL now, is Anna Sui’s Eyebrow Brush #1. Sure, it says for eyebrows, but really, it’s a mascara wand. It’s so gothicly girly like much of Sui’s beauty line, but because the handle gets thicker in the middle it’s quite ergonomically correct, too. It’s probably the easiest one to use that I’ve found, and it was quite reasonably priced, too. I dimly recall that I may have paid just under ten US dollars for it? While I can’t find it here in the States anymore, I’d be willing to bet those who live near any of Sui’s Asian outlets may still be able to get ahold of it. If Anna Sui still makes it, that is. Sigh. It’s fab, I hope it is still out there somewhere.
More mascara madness will follow on this blog later throughout this month, including reviews of some mid to high end mascaras. Because I’m addicted to beauty tools and brushes you’ll see some more of those too, including a tweezer that can, *gasp*, knock Tweezerman off its golden tweezer throne!
Much thanks goes to my friend Annie from Blogdorf Goodman for dreaming this May Mascara Madness idea up and organizing it. There are several other marvelous bloggers participating, so please check them all out! The list includes:
http://www.beautifulmakeupsearch.com/blog2/
http://beautyaddict.blogspot.com/
http://beautynews.blogspot.com/
http://blend10.blogspot.com/
http://thedailyobsession.wordpress.com/
http://beautydiary.blogspot.com/
http://www.ladybuglife.blogspot.com/
http://monkeyposh.blogspot.com/
http://thenonblonde.blogspot.com/
http://scentzilla.com/
http://after-so-much-thinking.blogspot.com/
http://victoriasown.blogspot.com/
On another and WHOLLY RANDOM topic, this cracked me up harder than anything I have ever seen. Well, anything I’ve seen this week anyhow, and that even includes this. My favorite line has to be ““I have included in this drink everything I could to strengthen the body.” Wow. I thought that was pure bloat on him, but it’s all strength, baby! Water-retaining, fatastic strength! No word yet on how the drink might affect fey little ponytails. It seems like only yesterday he was singing his own praises as a holyman/lama/whatever you say dude, and selling his organic snake lavender oil. According to that site, now he’s actually singing and cutting an album. WTF? links both via Defamer
Images: Top from physiciansformula.com. Second from newyorkcolor.com. Next from smashbox.com. Next from shuuemura-usa.com. Fifth from strawberrynet.com. Last one of Anna Sui brush from this eBay seller who is luckily willing to ship to the US! Whoo!